Review Guidelines

Each review must answer the following questions.

  • What does the paper do? One paragraph. This can be brief. 
  • What are the key insights of the paper? This is the key component of the review. What did you learn from the paper? What are the transferrable insights that you can remember and perhaps apply it later? I am not expecting more than a paragraph. But this part needs to be insightful. 
  • What are the positives in the paper? What did you like about it? A line or two. 
  • What are the negatives in the paper? What are its limitations. A line or two. 
  • Does the paper trigger any interesting follow-up questions? A paragraph. 

The whole review can be quite brief 300-500 words. Please focus your attention on the insights.